By Dele Sobowale
The arrest of one culprit merely opens a vacancy for other willing adventurers to fill and the beat goes on. What should worry us are the sources of funds to buy the N800bn seized. A great shock awaits us in 2024.
“Once to every man and nation comes the moment to decide, in the strife of truth and falsehood, for the good or evil side.” James Russell Lowell, 1819-1891.
No two years are ever alike in the history of any country. But, 2024 in Nigeria, will be characterised by three words: SCARCITY, FAILURE AND CHAOS.
Scarcity will be the most pervasive. The year is already going to start with cash scarcity – which is a hangover from the disastrous currency change programme early in the year. Others to expect include the following: foreign exchange, food, manufactured goods, drugs, jobs, university lecturers, doctors, nurses, and accommodation.
Scarcity, meanwhile, induces recurrent inflation – which means that, contrary to the assumptions in the budget, inflation in 2024 might top 30 per cent. Furthermore, a look at the list above should reveal to the reader that the situations in Nigeria make the shortages of supply inevitable.
For too long, Nigerians have been led by one political falsehood after another. As we start 2024, we are once more confronted with the government’s increasing credibility gap. Trust in governments, which binds the people of the great nations together, has been missing in Nigeria since 1960.
Governments, at Federal, State and Local Government levels now deceive the people so shamelessly and without remorse. Except for those in government, the beneficiaries of their activities (whatever those might be) and their party members few people believe the leaders anymore. Yet, rapid social, economic and political development will continue to elude us until faith in governments is restored.
Two quick questions will illustrate the point and lead us to the forecasts for 2024 – which unbelievably promises to be worse than any year before it. Hope delayed.
“Subsidy is gone.” President Bola Tinubu, May 29, 2023.
On vital national issues, a President should not speak flippantly and without meaning it; because lives of millions of stakeholders depend on his utterances. Thus, when Tinubu announced that “Subsidy is gone” in his inaugural address, and was roundly applauded for his “courage” and for “hitting the ground running”, my first comment on June 4, 2023, was “Talk is cheap”. Something told me that Tinubu had not fully considered all the implications of the policy decision. In less than 72 hours after, some of the repercussions came tumbling in.
Rattled, Tinubu was forced to call an Emergency Meeting of the National Economic Council, NEC. The NEC, which should have been consulted before making the announcement, joined the President in promising a lot of palliatives; most of which have not been delivered till today.
Right now a question which should have only one answer – Yes or No – has two answers; depending on who is talking. FG’s credibility and the fate of Nigerians in 2024 hang on the truth. Below are the answers given to the most important question for 2024.
Federal Government “Subsidy is gone, and the President told Nigerians from his first day in office that there won’t be subsidy…..There are instances where the government needs to come in to see that things don’t go bad…Every rule will also have its self-adjusting mechanism…” Mohammed Idris, Minister of Information and National Orientation on Channels TV.
World Bank “It does seem like petrol prices are not fully adjusting to market conditions. So, that hints at the partial return of the subsidy….We think the price of petrol should be around N750 litre – more than the N650/litre currently paid by Nigerians.” Alex Sienaert, Economist, World Bank.
Marketers “How can you say subsidy is gone? No reasonable person who knows the dynamics of the market globally will say that…The government is subsidising PMS [petrol] because, if it gets to N1000/litre, the country could be set on fire.”
Chief John Kekeocha, Secretary, Independent Petroleum Marketers Association of Nigeria. “Since the dollar is now about N1,100, if you buy it at that price for the purpose of importing petrol, that means PMS should be selling around N950 or N1000/litre…there is no magic about this.
Chief Ukadike Chinedu, National Public Relations Officer, IPMAN “Governments’ spokesmen are not appointed for their intelligence; but, for ability to dissemble publicly with a straight face. Obviously, irrespective of what the FG says, Nigerians should expect the following in 2024.
•Fuel subsidy officially returns •Despite that PMS price ranging between N750-1200/litre
President Tinubu will soon find out that talking first, thinking later can produce disastrous consequences.
ECONOMY 2024; Three major uncertainties hang on our heads like a sword – global price of crude, prevailing fuel price and exchange rates — we turn to the economy in 2024.
BUDGET; Only God knows when Nigeria will ever have a realistic budget presented by the FG to the National Assembly, NASS. As it is, the NASS is wasting time deliberating on a 2024 Budget that is already shredded by events beyond FG’s control. The budget will never be implemented. Here are the reasons.
•False Hope: Based on constant dollars, the Budget for 2024 represents 23 per cent decline from the 2023 Budget as shown below. •The 2023 Budget was later amended with a Supplementary appropriation to bring the total to N24.82tn.
Obviously, in more stable dollar terms, the 2024 Budget is 23 per cent less than the 2023 Budget. Hope? Forget it.
•Crude revenue estimates might not be achieved: USA and South American Non-OPEC Producers now pumping more oil; reducing OPEC/Nigeria’s share of crude oil exports. Export will average less than 1.6 million barrels per day on the average.
•Stunted Development: “Nigeria’s revenue not enough to support development — IMF.” “Dilapidated Power Plants, and erratic power supply will remain obstacles to economic development.
•Fuel Supply and Price Uncertainty: Despite Dangote Refinery coming on stream and the wasted efforts to revive Nigeria’s four refineries, the uncertainty of supplies and prices will make planning impossible for consumers. Expect either a return to subsidy or fuel price above N1000/litre in 2024.
•Expect more devaluation: The Budget was based on the N750/$1 exchange rate. CBN on December 17, 2023, announced a new exchange rate – N951/$1. That has already torn the 2024 to shreds.
•Inflation certainly above 30%: With the crude revenue target likely to be missed and total revenue in jeopardy, deficit spending will increase above budget and push inflation above 30 per cent in 2024.
•Scarcity of everything: cash scarcity, forex scarcity, food scarcity, imported inputs scarcity, housing scarcity, lecturers scarcity, proprietary drugs scarcity, job scarcity etc will propel inflation higher. Food scarcity deserves special mention. Hoodlums have a stranglehold on Nigeria’s food baskets – Kaduna, Katsina, Sokoto, Zamfara, Benue, Borno, Niger and Plateau. Yet, in 2024 Nigeria’s population will increase by at least six million mouths to feed while the 2023 harvest is estimated to be lower than what we had in 2022. Massive food importation is certain or else unprecedented famine will result.
•Manufacturing decline inevitable: the departure of multinationals, closure of their local suppliers; scarcity of cash, inputs and dollars portend shutdown of many manufacturing companies.
•Foreign Airlines Departure imminent: “$792M TRAPPED FUNDS: Foreign airlines at breaking point; may exit Nigeria” Report, December 11, 2023. the airlines face the same challenges as GSK and P&G; they cannot obtain dollars to remit their funds. For them, operating in Nigeria has become a matter of throwing good money after bad. The end is not in sight for intractable dollar scarcity.
•FDI declines further: “Chevron, ExxonMobil snub Nigeria in 2024 spending plan.” BUSINESSDAY, December 18, 2023. Capital is a coward; it seldom rushes in where others before it are jumping out in droves. To GSK and P&G, you can add, fully or partially, Jumia and Shoprite among those heading for the exit gate. Despite the over-blown successes of Tinubu’s foreign trips, the results are still in doubt. What is never in dispute is how foreigners determine whether to invest in an economy. Nigeria is losing on the major indices.
•Deficit/Loans/Debt burden/Repayment: tied together like quadruplets, the expectations for 2024 are the worst since the FG published annual budgets in Nigeria. Higher-than-expected deficits will start from January 1, 2024 as Nigeria’s export of crude will not reach 1.7 million per day. Higher deficits invariably lead to more loans than was budgeted. That inexorably means increased debt burden and higher debt to revenue ratio. Altogether, Nigerians can expect a dreadful performance in 2024.
Dele Sobowale is a Public Policy Analyst.
