In his defense of the Tinubu administration, the Minister of Solid Minerals, Dele Alake issued a confident challenge to Nigerians to name any civilian government in Nigeria’s history that has achieved more across the socio-economic and political space in three short years, or point to a viable alternative to the economic “shock therapy” administered since May 2023.
Minister Alake’s argument relies on a classic technocratic sleight-of-hand—substituting macro-level corporate and institutional corrections for micro-level human realities.
However, a blow-by-blow audit of his claims reveals why his narrative of “shared prosperity” collapses when confronted with the daily survival metrics of the average Nigerian household.
1. On “Broad-Spectrum Achievements” and “Shared Prosperity” Alake asserted that “every sector has been touched, moving Nigeria out of the doldrums into what we now call “shared prosperity.”
The Reality Check: To claim “shared prosperity” after a three-year stretch where food inflation breached historical highs (reaching a multi-decade peak of 34.8%), families spending over 120% of income on food, and millions, 63% of Nigeria’s population pushed into acute multi-dimensional poverty, is an exercise in political fantasy.
While federation revenues surged (thanks to multi-trillion-naira FAAC windfalls), that wealth remained trapped in government vaults and bank balance sheets. For the average Nigerian, prosperity was not shared; austerity was distributed universally.
2. On “Taking the Bullet” and the Skyscraper Foundation Metaphor, Alake claimed that restructuring an economy is like building a skyscraper where you need a deep foundation. According to him, Tinubu took the bullet because previous leaders lacked the courage to implement these reforms.
The Reality Check: Mr. Alake’s claim is faulty. Previous administrations indeed lacked the political will to remove the petrol subsidy and unify the exchange rate, choosing instead to kick the can down the road. But does he remember that this was his principal’s prescription even then? He requested a phased approach to subsidy removal.
Be that as it may, Alake’s architectural analogy exposes the Tinubu administration’s fatal flaw. When you dig the foundation of a skyscraper, professional builders do not detonate dynamite right beneath the building at the same time. The foundation will collapse. Taking the bullet is admirable only if you protect the citizens standing behind you.
By executing simultaneous, compounding shocks (subsidy removal plus FX devaluation plus electricity tariff hikes) without an effective, functioning social safety net, the administration proved it was willing to sacrifice the patient to save the hospital.
3. On Fuel Subsidy Removal and the “Cabal” Alake declared that subsidy was not profiting the average man but enriching smugglers, invoice-inflating importers, and a parasitic cabal.
The Reality Check: No serious economist defends the old petrol subsidy regime; it was an unsustainable, corrupt drain on national resources that mortgaged Nigeria’s future.
Yet, it is not impossible to give Nigerians a benefit for being producers of crude oil while ending a corrupt regime. Alake failed in defending the execution. Ending a subsidy that artificially suppressed fuel prices overnight-without first deploying mass transit alternatives, fixing domestic refineries, or cushioning transport cost – turned a necessary policy medicine into an immediate economic poison for ordinary citizens. The cabal was indeed sidelined, but the ordinary worker who now spends 400% more on commuting to a stagnant minimum-wage job paid the price.
4. On FX Unification, Garden-Chair Arbitrage, and “Micro-Benefits”, Alake claimed that FX Unification eliminated corrupt arbitrage where well-connected people made billions sitting in gardens. The micro-benefits according to him are clearing $7 billion in airline backlogs and restoring international card usage so Nigerians can spend abroad.
The Reality Check: This is perhaps the most glaring disconnect in the administration’s defense. Clearing the $7 billion foreign exchange backlog and restoring international credit card transactions are genuine victories for corporate balance sheets, foreign investors, and multinational airlines.
But defining the restoration of international credit card usage and airline profit repatriation as “micro-benefits” reveals an extraordinary elite bias. The average Nigerian does not swipe cards in London or book international flights; they struggle to buy a bag of local rice or pay school fees.
Celebrating corporate FX liquidity while local manufacturing plants shut down due to high borrowing costs and FX volatility is evidence of an administration talking to investors while ignoring its own citizens.
On the whole, with the mounting rejection confronting President Tinubu’s re-election bid, one is not surprised by Alake’s panicky, halfway exercise in political damage control.
Alake should know that great economic reforms across history are remembered for the magnitude of prosperity they deliver and not for sufferings inflicted. A government that delivers hardship to its citizens and prosperity to its balance sheets cannot credibly claim to have achieved shared prosperity.
What Nigeria needs now is a governance RESET as envisioned by the Presidential candidate of the Allied Peoples Movement (APM), Engr. Seyi Makinde; a RESET that guarantees expanded opportunities, fiscal discipline, micro and real macroeconomic stability that positively impact on the lives of millions of citizens
Signed:
Richard Nnanna Ihediwa
Director of Strategic Communications
Makinde-Daura Presidential Campaign Organization
Never miss a moment! Get the stories shaping Nigeria, delivered straight to your phone. Follow Peoplesdaily Newspaper on WhatsApp for breaking news, exclusive reports, and the headlines everyone will be talking about, before anyone else.

