New Delhi, India — The southernmost point of India, the Great Nicobar Island, is closer to the coasts of Thailand, Malaysia and Indonesia than it is to the Indian mainland.
No Indian prime minister has visited the island, which is the size of Hong Kong, since Indira Gandhi in 1984. India does not even conduct a full census on the island, relying on estimates of its population; the latest guess is that fewer than 10,000 people live there.
Yet the island is now in the eye of a political storm over an $11bn project planned by Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government to turn Great Nicobar into a major strategic and economic outpost in the Indian Ocean.
The Modi government has greenlit plans to build a transhipment port, a civilian-military airport, a power plant, tourism infrastructure and a township for 350,000 people on the island.
In its blueprint, the government highlighted the economics of maritime trade as the justification for the project.
But in the face of growing criticism from global environmental watchdogs and opposition leaders in New Delhi, the Indian government has shifted its narrative to position the plan as central to the country’s strategic goals in its neighbourhood.
And the United States-Iran struggle over the Strait of Hormuz has given that vision a boost, serving as a reminder of the importance of a perch that can serve military and economic aims over a strategic waterway — in this case, the Strait of Malacca, through which a third of global trade and seaborne oil flows.
“This island has a strategic value because it is sitting right at the mouth of Malacca [strait],” Shekhar Sinha, a former vice chief of the Indian Navy, told Al Jazeera. “And if it is [developed as] a commercial setup,” he added, no one would be able to object.
Sentry against China?
Stretching into the southeastern end of the Bay of Bengal, the Great Nicobar Island sits nearly 1,600km (994 miles) from mainland India, near the western approaches to the Strait of Malacca. It lies adjacent to East-West shipping lanes that carry trade and supplies between the Gulf, Europe and East Asia, including China, Japan and South Korea.
It is only 2.8km (1.7-mile) wide at its narrowest at the Phillip Channel near Singapore, yet it is the principal body of water connecting the Middle East to Southeast Asia.
Get instant alerts and updates based on your interests. Be the first to know when big stories happen.
Yes, keep me updated
And while the world’s trade depends on this strait, it is especially critical for China, which relies on the route for 80 percent of its crude oil imports and two-thirds of its trade.
That geography makes Great Nicobar a potentially valuable sentry for India, watching over the Strait of Malacca.
“It is a great place to monitor all the traffic, coming in and out of the strait,” Sinha said. “It would give India an edge in maritime domain awareness,” referring to New Delhi’s ability to track and monitor activity at sea.
The Modi government has in recent weeks increasingly acknowledged the strategic value of the island.
The Great Nicobar project “is a strategic project which aims to strengthen India’s presence in the Andaman Sea and Southeast Asia,” the government noted in a press release in May. “The project is designed to enhance India’s national security, strategic and defence presence, strengthen the islands’ economic position, and accelerate holistic development in the region.”
‘A death sentence’
Yet that is not how the project was envisaged, at least in the government’s official vision. Rather, it was pitched to rival the deepwater port-led economies of Singapore, Sri Lanka’s Colombo and even Hong Kong.
The government’s plans quickly faced stiff resistance, including from the inhabitants of the island, who have since refused to give up their lands to make way for the construction and have filed cases against the government’s plans in multiple courts.
Last in the chain of the Nicobar Islands, the Great Nicobar is home to a few hundred Shompens, a seminomadic hunter-gatherer tribe living in dense forest interiors, and a few thousand fishing-dependent Nicobarese who survive on the elegant ecosystem.
The Indigenous communities maintain distance from the outside world and the settler population on the island, which is spread over about 1,000sq km (400sq miles).
The government’s project is currently planned on 166.1sq km of land, roughly 16 percent of the entire island. Half of this land overlaps with tribal reserve areas, which the Shompens inhabit.
In February 2024, 39 genocide experts wrote to Indian President Droupadi Murmu, warning that the project would be “a death sentence for the Shompen”, tantamount to the international crime of genocide.
India’s environment minister informed Parliament in 2023 that nearly 964,000 trees would be felled for the project. The development would also displace the native fishing-dependent Nicobarese community and make way for the settlement of 350,000 people over the next three decades.
If that happens, it would mean a 4,000 percent population increase on the island.
The ancestral lands of the Nicobarese community have been marked for a tourism zone under the project, even as their protests against it continue.
The Indian government has maintained that the criticism is unfounded and that the project will be a model for a holistic approach towards island development.
But activists warn the project would severely disrupt Great Nicobar’s fragile ecology through large-scale deforestation, coastal alteration and infrastructure construction in one of India’s most biodiverse island ecosystems.
The island also falls in seismic zone 5, the highest earthquake-risk category, making large construction projects on Great Nicobar particularly vulnerable.
Rahul Gandhi, India’s leader of the opposition, visited the island a month ago and met local activists and affected people. Writing on his X handle later, the Congress party leader said: “The government calls what it is doing here a ‘Project’ … It is communities that have been ignored while their homes have been snatched away. This is destruction dressed in development’s language.”
Gandhi claimed that the Great Nicobar project was “one of the biggest scams and gravest crimes against this country’s natural and tribal heritage in our lifetime”.
He also visited the Indira Point Lighthouse, the southernmost tip of Indian territory, named after his grandmother and former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi.
That lighthouse, once surrounded by lush trees, stands partially submerged in the water.
Source: ALJAZEERA
